Why Smart Buyers Choose Used Sports Cars
The sports car market has shifted dramatically, with new performance vehicles often starting above $30,000. However, savvy car buyers know that late-model used sports cars offer the same driving excitement at significantly lower prices. Using Carma's community pricing data, you can identify vehicles with strong resale value and negotiate deals that traditional pricing tools might miss.
Our Selection Criteria
We focused on vehicles with less than 60,000 miles from the current generation of three standout models. Each has proven reliability, strong aftermarket support, and holds value well in the used market. These picks represent the sweet spot where performance meets affordability.
1. 2016-Present Mazda MX-5 Miata
The current-generation Miata remains the gold standard for affordable sports car thrills. With 155-181 horsepower depending on model year, this lightweight roadster prioritizes handling precision over straight-line speed.

2016 Mazda MX-5 Miata
View ListingsPros
- Exceptional handling and steering feel
- Reliable naturally aspirated engine
- Strong resale value holds pricing power
- Available in hardtop RF configuration
Cons
- Limited cargo space for practicality
- Two seats only restricts passengers
- Cabin can feel cramped for taller drivers
- Minimal storage compartments
The fourth-generation MX-5's low weight makes every drive engaging, whether you choose the standard soft-top or the retractable hardtop RF variant. Manual transmission models offer the purest driving experience, though automatics retain much of the car's character. Market data shows these hold value exceptionally well, making them smart long-term investments.
When shopping for used Miatas, prioritize maintenance records over absolute lowest mileage. A well-maintained higher-mileage example often represents better value than a neglected low-mileage car. Look for evidence of regular oil changes and avoid examples with aftermarket modifications unless professionally installed.
2. 2022-Present Subaru BRZ
The second-generation BRZ addresses many complaints about its predecessor while maintaining the engaging rear-wheel-drive dynamics that made it popular. With four seats and a more practical trunk, it offers sports car thrills with daily usability.

2022 Subaru BRZ
View ListingsPros
- Four seats add passenger flexibility
- Practical cargo space with fold-down rear seats
- Improved engine response over previous generation
- Lower depreciation than luxury sports cars
Cons
- Manual transmission feels notchy compared to Miata
- Rear seats only suitable for children
- Higher price point than some alternatives
- Limited aftermarket warranty coverage
The current BRZ strikes an excellent balance between performance and practicality. Its naturally aspirated boxer engine delivers linear power delivery that rewards precise throttle control. While not the most powerful in its class, the BRZ's balanced chassis makes it incredibly rewarding to drive within legal speed limits.
Being relatively new to the used market, 2022-2023 BRZ models command strong prices but offer modern features and remaining factory warranty coverage. Focus your search on vehicles with complete service records and consider certified pre-owned programs for additional peace of mind.
3. 2022-Present Toyota GR86
Sharing its platform with the BRZ, the GR86 offers identical performance with subtle styling differences. Toyota's version often provides better dealer network support and potentially stronger resale value due to brand perception.

2022 Toyota GR86
View ListingsPros
- Toyota reliability reputation supports resale
- Identical performance to BRZ with style differences
- Extensive dealer network for service support
- Strong aftermarket parts availability
Cons
- Higher demand may inflate used prices
- Same rear seat limitations as BRZ
- Premium over BRZ not always justified
- Limited color and trim availability
The GR86 delivers the same thrilling driving dynamics as its Subaru sibling while benefiting from Toyota's extensive dealer network. Mechanical components are virtually identical, so your choice often comes down to styling preference and local dealer support quality.
Market conditions sometimes favor one twin over the other, so compare both when shopping. The GR86's Toyota badge may command a premium, but savvy buyers can often find better deals on the mechanically identical BRZ.
Smart Shopping Strategies
Success in the used sports car market requires patience and preparation. Start by researching typical pricing for your target vehicle using community data to understand fair market values. This knowledge becomes crucial during negotiations with dealers or private sellers.
Pre-Purchase Checklist
| Item | Why Important | Red Flags |
|---|---|---|
| Professional Inspection | Identifies hidden mechanical issues | Seller refuses inspection |
| Service Records | Shows maintenance consistency | Missing major service intervals |
| Vehicle History | Reveals accidents or flood damage | Title issues or gaps in history |
| Test Drive | Evaluates clutch and transmission | Slipping clutch or grinding gears |
| Modification Check | Assesses aftermarket changes | Poor installation or extreme mods |
Pay special attention to the clutch condition on manual transmission models. During your test drive, accelerate in the highest gear around 40 mph. If engine RPMs rise faster than vehicle speed increases, the clutch may need replacement soon—a significant expense to factor into your offer.
Find Your Perfect Sports Car Deal
Use Carma's community pricing data to identify undervalued sports cars in your area and negotiate with confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are used sports cars under $25K reliable for daily driving?
Yes, the models we've highlighted—particularly the Mazda MX-5 Miata, Subaru BRZ, and Toyota GR86—are built on proven platforms with strong reliability records. However, sports cars typically require more maintenance attention than economy vehicles. Regular oil changes, tire rotations, and brake inspections become more critical due to performance-oriented driving. Budget for higher maintenance costs and premium fuel requirements. A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic can identify potential issues before you buy.
Should I avoid modified sports cars when shopping used?
Generally, yes, unless modifications are professionally installed and well-documented. Sports cars attract enthusiastic owners who often modify them, but aftermarket changes can indicate aggressive driving or poor installation quality. If you find a modified example you like, verify that all work was done by reputable shops with proper documentation. Ask if original parts are included with the sale. Simple modifications like intakes or exhaust systems are less concerning than engine tuning or suspension modifications that may affect reliability or warranty coverage.
How much should I negotiate below asking price on these sports cars?
Negotiation room varies by market conditions, vehicle condition, and seller motivation. Research comparable sales in your area using community pricing data to establish a fair value baseline. Generally, you might negotiate 5-10% below asking price for dealer vehicles, potentially more for private sales. Focus on total cost of ownership rather than just purchase price—factor in immediate needs like tires, brakes, or maintenance. Strong documentation and clean history command higher prices, while high mileage or cosmetic issues provide negotiating leverage.
What's the most important factor when choosing between these three sports cars?
Your intended use should drive the decision. Choose the MX-5 Miata if you prioritize pure driving engagement and don't need rear seats or significant cargo space. The roadster experience is unmatched for weekend drives and spirited back-road adventures. Select the BRZ or GR86 if you need occasional rear seating and more practical cargo capacity for daily use. Both twins offer similar performance with subtle differences in styling and dealer support. Consider your local dealer network quality and available inventory when choosing between the Subaru and Toyota versions.
Ready to save on your next car?
Join the Carma community and get access to real deal data from thousands of car buyers.
